Skip to content

Got a roofing quote? Check it before you sign.

Review whether your roofing proposal clearly explains the materials, tear-off, flashing, ventilation, permits, cleanup, warranties, payments and timeline. See missing details and useful questions to ask before you decide.

  • Free first check
  • No contractor contacted
  • No phone required

Step 1 of 5

Project

What a good roofing quote should explain

  • •Material brand and grade
  • •Tear-off and disposal
  • •Underlayment
  • •Flashing
  • •Ventilation
  • •Permit handling
  • •Cleanup
  • •Warranty
  • •Payment schedule
  • •Start and completion timeline

What we check in your roofing quote

Material brand and grade. A complete quote names the exact shingle manufacturer and product line — not just "architectural shingles." The brand and grade determine warranty length and storm resistance.

Tear-off and disposal. Laying new shingles over old ones is sometimes acceptable and sometimes a code violation. The quote should state whether old material is removed and who pays for dumpster and disposal fees.

Underlayment. Synthetic felt or self-adhering ice-and-water barriers differ in cost and protection. A quote that omits underlayment type makes price comparison impossible.

Flashing. Step flashing around chimneys, skylights, and walls is where most leaks originate. The quote should state whether existing flashing is reused or replaced.

Ventilation. Ridge vents, soffit vents, and attic baffles affect both energy efficiency and shingle warranty validity. A quote that ignores ventilation may cost you more later.

Permit handling. Many roofing replacements require a permit; requirements vary by city and county. The quote should state who pulls it and confirm that inspections are included.

Cleanup. Job-site cleanup, nail sweeping, and haul-away should be explicitly included. "Broom clean" is the minimum; confirm what it means.

Warranty. There are two separate warranties: manufacturer's product warranty (covering materials) and contractor's workmanship warranty (covering installation). Both should appear in writing with durations.

Payment schedule. A large upfront payment before work starts is a red flag. The quote should state deposit amount, progress milestones, and final payment terms. For covered California home-improvement contracts, the general down-payment limit is the lesser of 10% of the contract price or $1,000, subject to applicable exceptions; confirm the current rule with the CSLB. Other states have their own rules.

Timeline. Start date, estimated duration, and what happens if hidden damage (rotten decking, damaged trusses) is found should all appear in the quote.

Comparing two roofing quotes?

The total price alone does not tell you whether they cover the same work. Check each quote, then compare what each one explains and leaves out.

Review another quote ↑

Who this is for

  • •Homeowners who have a roofing quote in hand and want to know what's missing before signing.
  • •Homeowners comparing two or more quotes who want to level the playing field on scope.
  • •Homeowners who want answers about their quote without triggering sales calls from contractors.

What happens after the check

  1. 1Submit your quote or fill in the checklist.
  2. 2Review the present, unclear and missing sections.
  3. 3Ask for clarification, then recheck if the proposal changes.
  4. 4Optionally save the quote to your HomeGoSmart property and connect it to the roof's history (coming with the HomeGoSmart app; not available yet).

Frequently asked questions

Is the roofing quote check free?

Yes. Submit your roofing quote and get a quote completeness score, a list of missing items, and the questions to ask your contractor — no payment, no account, and no phone number required. We ask for an email so we can send you the checklist.

Will my contractor know I checked their quote?

No. The quote check is between you and HomeGoSmart. We never contact your contractor or share the results of your check with them.

Do I need to share my phone number?

No. Your phone number is optional throughout the quote check process. We only ask for it if you explicitly request a second opinion or vendor match, and we never share it with anyone without your consent.

Can I check a quote if I haven't picked a roofer yet?

Yes. You can paste or upload any roofing quote — even one from a contractor you're still evaluating. The clarity score and checklist help you compare quotes and know what to ask before you decide.

What does the quote completeness score measure?

It reflects how completely a quote covers ten items a good roofing proposal should include: material brand and grade, tear-off and disposal, underlayment, flashing, ventilation, permit handling, cleanup, warranty, payment schedule, and start and completion timeline. Missing items lower the score. It measures whether key subjects are addressed, not quality of workmanship, contractor honesty, project safety or overall value.

Does a high score mean the roofer is reliable?

No. It only reflects completeness of the proposal against the checklist. Verify licenses, insurance, references and the contract independently.

Is the checker only for California?

The educational checklist can help homeowners across the United States. California-specific contractor referrals are a limited pilot and local rules vary. California down-payment rules are only applied to quotes with a California ZIP code.

What happens to my uploaded file?

Uploaded quotes and photos are stored in private storage linked to your quote check, so our team can review them if you ask for a second opinion. They are not shared with contractors. Today the check reads the text you paste; it does not read uploaded files automatically. To have your upload deleted, email privacy@homegosmart.com.

Can I keep the quote in my property record?

Not yet. Saving a quote to a HomeGoSmart property requires the HomeGoSmart app, which isn't available yet. You can print your result and keep the emailed checklist.